Our menu

Cake Flavors & Fillings

Every great cake starts with the perfect flavor! Explore our selection of classic favorites and signature creations to find the perfect combination for your celebration.

Baked fresh

Basic cake flavors

Included in standard cake pricing

Vanilla

A soft, fluffy vanilla cake with a smooth, classic flavor that pairs beautifully with any filling.

Chocolate

A rich, moist chocolate cake with a deep cocoa flavor for all the chocolate lovers.

Lemon

A light, refreshing lemon cake with a bright citrus flavor and a touch of sweetness.

Strawberry

A soft, sweet strawberry cake with a delicious flavor in every bite.

Mix and match

Pair any cake flavor with any filling — your cake, your rules! If you don't see a combination you're dreaming of, just ask when you request your quote.

Signature favorites

Signature cake flavors

$5 additional charge

Key Lime

A refreshing cake inspired by the classic key lime dessert, featuring a sweet and tangy citrus flavor.

Red Velvet

A southern classic. Tender, velvety cake with a subtle cocoa flavor.

Carrot Cake

A moist, warmly spiced cake with delicious carrot flavor and a comforting blend of spices.

Marble

The best of both worlds! A beautiful combination of vanilla and chocolate cake swirled together.

Cookies & Cream

A delicious vanilla-based cake filled with chocolate cookie pieces for a classic cookies-and-cream taste.

Vanilla Funfetti

A fluffy vanilla cake filled with colorful sprinkles for a fun and festive touch.

Strawberry Swirl

A delicious vanilla cake with sweet strawberry swirls throughout, bringing together two classic flavors.

Inside the cake

Cake fillings

Choose the perfect filling to complement your cake!

Included with your cake

Traditional Whipped Buttercream

A light, fluffy, and smooth buttercream with a sweet, creamy finish. Included with your cake.

Upgrade your cake

Signature fillings

$5 - $10 additional charge.

Cream Cheese

A rich and creamy filling with a smooth texture and a slight tang.

Strawberries & Cream

A sweet and creamy combination of fresh strawberries and fresh whipped cream.

Biscoff

A rich, creamy cookie butter filling with the warm, caramelized flavor of Biscoff cookies.

Chocolate Buttercream

A smooth, fluffy chocolate buttercream with a rich cocoa flavor.

Cookies & Cream

A creamy filling blended with crushed chocolate sandwich cookies.

Reese's Peanut Butter

A crunchy, peanut butter filling inspired by the classic Reese's flavor combination.

A little note about your cake

All Tay's Pastries cakes are finished with our signature whipped buttercream on the outside for a smooth, beautiful finish.

Allergen notice

Our products may contain or come into contact with dairy, eggs, wheat, and/or nuts. Please be cautious of food allergens when placing your order. If you have any food allergies or dietary concerns, please communicate them when submitting your inquiry.

Found your flavor?

Tell me your flavor combo and the details of your celebration, and I'll get baking.